The generation after Socrates' death, his philosophies were made very popular by those who knew him, one of whom was Plato. Plato had a student named Aristotle, who is maybe the most influential person in history with his development of biological studies, logic, and psychology. Aristotle was undoubtedly a learned man and a scholar; however, there are many, myself included, who don't believe he was truly a genius.
Aristotle was very, very popular. He also had an insatiable thirst for knowledge. He was embraced by the public and religious leaders as one who expanded on Plato and Socrates. However, it is the last item in the series that causes the question of Aristotle's genius.
Aristotle seemed to have an amazing ability to look at something and explain how it worked. What has proven out later is that Aristotle seems to have compromised his principles for popularity. People wanted answers, perhaps confirmations, and he would produce them even if he didn't really know what he was talking about.
Two conclusions of Aristotle's that demonstrate his lack of genius were:
* Earth is the center of the universe, and stars were made from a 'perfect material' not found on Earth.
* The male gender in all species is larger and has more teeth.
Not only did Aristotle make these mathematical errors in his reasoning, he also accepted prestigious positions, taught for money, and fled his own fairly-certain execution only to die naturally within the year. These compromises of Socratian ethics indicate that he was in it for more than just passing knowledge on to future generations, and that he feared death.
He also added an inductive reasoning philosophy to Plato's description of Socrates' deductive methods. Starting at the beginning is a lineal thought, and served mainly to verify erroneous logic. To wit: Aristotle believed that if Earth was not the center of everything, then things in the air would be left behind as Earth flew through the sky. Inductively, he verified this by noting that birds aren't left behind in flight, ergo the Earth stays in one place.
His conclusions were the main argument against the mathemetician's Aristarchus of Namos claim a few decades later that Earth is in a solar system, rotates, and orbits the sun. Not until Copernicus, about 1,700 years later, would the genius of Aristarchus of Namos be recognized. Many of the scientific errors in the Bible can be directly attributed to Aristotle's teachings and the churches embracing of his 'verifying conclusions.'
So let's evaluate Aristotle's genius:
Was Aristotle a genius?
According to Kant's definition: Aristotle certainly appeared to be able to know that which others would need to be taught, but one would have to accept that Kant meant that a genius only needs to believe he knows what others would need to be taught. He was able to create new things. My conclusion is that according to Kant's definition, Aristotle was not a genius because he 'really didn't know that which he professed to know.'
With Schopenhauer's added definition: Aristotle appears to have put the will to live ahead of intellect. My conclusion is that he doesn't qualify according to Schopenhauer.
According to my criteria:
1. Aristotle was likely a conceptual thinker (he was entrepreneurial), but often fell prey to lineal conclusions.
2. Aristotle seemed to be able to compute math in ways common people can't, but he seemed to rely on prejudices to discount the math (i.e. he was correct in his math that if stars are the same things as our sun, then they would have to be millions of miles away.) However, he apparently didn't count the number of teeth in both genders of humans.
3. I haven't drawn a conclusion.
4. Aristotle seems to have used the creative side to consider options, but relied on his analytical side to draw many of his erroneous conclusions.
5. Aristotle's theories certainly have affected future generations, but not necessarily positively. His conclusions set astronomy back nearly 2,000 years, and modern religion is still flawed by erroneous Aristotlian presumptions.
6. He seems to have not been able to envision a million miles.
7. Aristotle appears to have understood the importance of physical laws and dynamics, but seems to have discounted some of it due to prejudices about limitations.
8. Aristotle appears to have had a misogynistic prejudice, and sought wealth and fame. When it came to death, he abandoned his principles totally.
9. Aristotle's conclusions demonstrate a blind faith that the male gender is superior to the female gender in all species, and that there are boundaries to reality.
By all three definitions, Aristotle does not seem to rate as a genius.
This is probably best verified when, in challenging Aristachrus's theory of the sun being the center of the solar system, it was popularly discounted for lacking the 'common sense' of Aristotle's conclusions!
Showing posts with label socrates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label socrates. Show all posts
Friday, June 22, 2007
Socrates: a Philosophical Genius
Socrates is considered the 'father of western philosophy.' He was an Athenian who lived in the fifth century before Christ. There is no evidence that he ever wrote his own thoughts down; what we know about him is from Plato's and Xenophon's writings, and the plays of Aristophanes. He is portrayed as a poor man who listened to a divine voice in his head, and who was pious. He placed great value on good, justice, beauty, and virtue. He accepted his execution, apparently with options, as a matter of principles.
He lived during a time when the general philosophy of 'right and wrong' was determined by who could win a battle. He is described as a 'gadfly' who would undermine the establishment's philosophy of 'might is right' with the Athenian people, to one of consideration for justice and good. He became such a pain in the butt that he was eventually executed for corrupting youth - this in a society where men having sex with boys was accepted! (Forget about that; his life has an e=mc2 factor that is long ago and far away.)
One of his philosophies, perhaps his most important one, is known as 'the Socratic method.' Through the method, a problem is solved by asking a question and finding an hypothesis (answer) that doesn't have conflict. It is the basis of 'the scientific method' used still today. He believed that the 'best results' (note: not 'correct' result) were derived from 'searching one's soul' (paraphrased) and asking others for input.
Other thoughts attributed to Socrates, by the sources we have, include:
* People spend too much time worrying about family and careers, and too little time worrying about the 'welfare of their souls.'
* Moral excellence is the result of one accepting divine inspiration than parental nurturing.
* His wisdom was not pretending to know that which he didn't.
* People should be more dedicated to self-development than gathering wealth.
* The job of a philosopher is to show others how little we know.
* People should be governed by philosophers, and not by democratic popularity.
* We live because of a life force that departs the body upon death.
* A true philosopher cannot fear death.
* One should honor his contracts regardless of the consequences.
Many people in Athens loved Socrates and thought him to be the wisest man in Athens. We can't know for certain that he was the wisest in the land, but he was, at least, regarded by some to be. Despite offers to help him escape, including the bribing of the guards, he accepted the court's decision, and considered his execution 'his answer to dying of old age.'
Question: Was Socrates a genius?
Applying Kant's definition: Socrates appears to be a man who knew what others would have to be taught, and was able to create methods for moral and ethical self-evaluation.
Applying Schopenhauer's addition to Kant's definition: Socrates appears to be a man who placed intellect predominate to will.
Applying my standards:
1. Socrates was a conceptual thinker.
2. The Socratic method is a demonstration of his understanding of using math uncommonly.
3. His relief over not having to die naturally and painfully demonstrates an understanding about how time works.
4. He used creativity and analysis to arrive at his conclusions.
5. His theories have added to the knowledge base for future geniuses.
6. He believed in a 'physical soul' and reincarnation that lived on after physical death. This doesn't demonstrate fully the envisionment of infinity, but it does show that he understood continuum.
7. His observation about 'genetic myths' of the day demonstrates an understanding of bodily physical laws and human dynamics.
8. He suffered execution over his principles.
9. He was incapable of accepting the norm claiming that he could become rich if he were to use his knowledge for pandering. He had no blind faith.
Socrates was a genius by all three standards.
So, if you're wondering why I'm going through this exercise to arrive at the conclusion that Socrates was a genius, the continuing story of Socrates and his 'posthumous recognition' as a genius led to him becoming prophetic. We'll skip Plato. He was a genius also. However, you should not just accept my word for that!
We need to go one more generation. Plato has already set up his school, and is teaching Socratic philosophy to students. Then one day, he died, and Aristotle became Plato's 'self-professed desciple.
He lived during a time when the general philosophy of 'right and wrong' was determined by who could win a battle. He is described as a 'gadfly' who would undermine the establishment's philosophy of 'might is right' with the Athenian people, to one of consideration for justice and good. He became such a pain in the butt that he was eventually executed for corrupting youth - this in a society where men having sex with boys was accepted! (Forget about that; his life has an e=mc2 factor that is long ago and far away.)
One of his philosophies, perhaps his most important one, is known as 'the Socratic method.' Through the method, a problem is solved by asking a question and finding an hypothesis (answer) that doesn't have conflict. It is the basis of 'the scientific method' used still today. He believed that the 'best results' (note: not 'correct' result) were derived from 'searching one's soul' (paraphrased) and asking others for input.
Other thoughts attributed to Socrates, by the sources we have, include:
* People spend too much time worrying about family and careers, and too little time worrying about the 'welfare of their souls.'
* Moral excellence is the result of one accepting divine inspiration than parental nurturing.
* His wisdom was not pretending to know that which he didn't.
* People should be more dedicated to self-development than gathering wealth.
* The job of a philosopher is to show others how little we know.
* People should be governed by philosophers, and not by democratic popularity.
* We live because of a life force that departs the body upon death.
* A true philosopher cannot fear death.
* One should honor his contracts regardless of the consequences.
Many people in Athens loved Socrates and thought him to be the wisest man in Athens. We can't know for certain that he was the wisest in the land, but he was, at least, regarded by some to be. Despite offers to help him escape, including the bribing of the guards, he accepted the court's decision, and considered his execution 'his answer to dying of old age.'
Question: Was Socrates a genius?
Applying Kant's definition: Socrates appears to be a man who knew what others would have to be taught, and was able to create methods for moral and ethical self-evaluation.
Applying Schopenhauer's addition to Kant's definition: Socrates appears to be a man who placed intellect predominate to will.
Applying my standards:
1. Socrates was a conceptual thinker.
2. The Socratic method is a demonstration of his understanding of using math uncommonly.
3. His relief over not having to die naturally and painfully demonstrates an understanding about how time works.
4. He used creativity and analysis to arrive at his conclusions.
5. His theories have added to the knowledge base for future geniuses.
6. He believed in a 'physical soul' and reincarnation that lived on after physical death. This doesn't demonstrate fully the envisionment of infinity, but it does show that he understood continuum.
7. His observation about 'genetic myths' of the day demonstrates an understanding of bodily physical laws and human dynamics.
8. He suffered execution over his principles.
9. He was incapable of accepting the norm claiming that he could become rich if he were to use his knowledge for pandering. He had no blind faith.
Socrates was a genius by all three standards.
So, if you're wondering why I'm going through this exercise to arrive at the conclusion that Socrates was a genius, the continuing story of Socrates and his 'posthumous recognition' as a genius led to him becoming prophetic. We'll skip Plato. He was a genius also. However, you should not just accept my word for that!
We need to go one more generation. Plato has already set up his school, and is teaching Socratic philosophy to students. Then one day, he died, and Aristotle became Plato's 'self-professed desciple.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Working William
William is my best friend at this point of my life. He has an uncommon developed talent for understanding processes, though I don't thin...
-
The generation after Socrates' death, his philosophies were made very popular by those who knew him, one of whom was Plato. Plato had a ...
-
. . . does ice come to a boil faster than cold water? No. Hot, which is arbitrary depending on the application, is acheived by the 'pres...
-
e=mc 2 ; so what does it mean? It is how time works. I haven't actually studied what Einstein wrote, so forgive me if I don't use th...